The traditional woman advocates essentially acknowledge that women are not treated the same as men in todays society, but try to refute the assertion that this disparity is. Feminist jurisprudence, edited by patricia smith, 1993, p. Discuss and promote awareness of issues related to equality for women. Feminist jurisprudence has raised various comments and critiques against the traditional malecentered jurisprudence. Feminist jurisprudence routledge encyclopedia of philosophy.
However, it does not do so by conducting a historical inquiry designed to restore forgotten female jurists or reveal womens contributions to the jurisprudential tradition. Current issues in feminist jurisprudence legal definition of. This in a society strongly founded upon a maleorientated legal system, which historically fails to recognise the social and legal. A philosophy of law based on the political, economic, and social equality of the sexes. One of the ways law is not neutral is through the individual people that work in law. Although most of the people writing about feminist jurisprudence are women, a few men like kenneth karst in womans constitution, 1984 duke l. Scholarship in this area began in the 1960s, although pioneers agitating for the womens right to vote and other important steps for equality began. Barnettintroduction to feminist jurisprudence 1998. Berkowitz, cb 294307, in light of any of the readings assigned to date. The feminist jurisprudence movement appears to have originated in the usa in the 1970s, possibly as part of the critical legal studies movement.
Feminism as a theory of law essay 2078 words bartleby. Feminist jurisprudence includes the study of different strands of feminist theory and the themes that have emerged and developed within feminist thought, as well as the application of theory to issues that interest members of class. The manwoman difference and the dominancesubmission dynamic define each other. Predictably, law is associated with the male side of the dualisms, in that it is supposed to be rational, objective, abstract and principled. Introduction to feminist jurisprudence hilaire barnett ba, llm queen mary and westfield college university of london cavendish publishing limited london sydney. I am going to discuss the development of feminist theories as to the sources of gender inequality and its pervasiveness, and the different feminist political solutions and. Feminist jurisprudence is a burgeoning school of legal thought that encompasses many theories and approaches to law and legal issues. Introduction to feminist jurisprudence request pdf. Subsequent chapters examine topics such as violence, reproduction, intimate relationships, children, employment, and education. See smart, feminist jurisprudence, supra note 1, at 17. Feminist jurisprudence internet encyclopedia of philosophy. Through litigation, campaigns for legal reform and legal education, feminists have engaged explicitly with law and the. First, feminist jurisprudence seeks to explain ways in which the law played a role in womens former subordinate status. Feminist jurisprudence is a broad church and reflects different strands of feminist thought but the unifying theme is that society and in particular, the legal system is patriarchal.
This book provides a student text covering the major issues in feminist jurisprudence and to analyse the manner in which both traditional jurisprudence and law have remained a masculine subject. Feminism is a set of movement seeking gender equality, a. Basic problems in east asian feminist jurisprudence. Feminist jurisprudence the first recorded use of the phrase feminist jurisprudence occurred in 1978 at a conference celebrating the twentyfifth anniversary of women graduates of the harvard law school.
What is equality or an injury in light of broader understandings of those norms. London sydney introduction to feminist jurisprudence. Apr 23, 2020 feminist jurisprudence is an approach to legal scholarship and practice that views the law through a feminist lens to examine the impact of current and past legal trends on the lives of women. Perhaps this is a reason why feminist jurisprudence is often categorized with liberalism or radicalism.
It is against the masculine symbolic order and within the critical development of postapartheid jurisprudence that i engage in tentative reflections on a feminist jurisprudence. Feminist legal philosophy has generated a great deal of interest among feminists, philosophers, legal scholars, sociologists and political scientists in recent years. Providing balanced coverage of abortion, sexual harassment, censorship and pornography, and other timely and controversial subjects, this pathbreaking anthology is the first to offer a comprehensive introduction to feminist legal philosophy. Male and female are created through the erotization of dominance and submission. Feminist philosophy of law stanford encyclopedia of. As a field of legal scholarship,feminist jurisprudence began in 1960s. The readings in this collection are organized according to the traditional topics in a typical this anthology is designed for use in courses in feminist jurisprudence. Examining the concept of feminist jurisprudence sociology essay.
Feminist jurisprudence is the feminist perspective on the methodology of law. Each strain of feminist jurisprudence evaluates and critiques the law by examining the relationship between gender, sexuality, power, individual rights, and the judicial system as a whole. The feminist jurisprudence is a much debated as well. The readings are organized according to the traditional topics in a typical jurisprudence course. Introduction to feminist jurisprudence, by hilaire barnett. Contemplating a postapartheid feminist jurisprudence.
Why law must consider womens perspectives abstract a growing number of scholars are asking how the law would be different if it took womens points of view and experiences into account. Bowman, cynthia, rosenbury, laura, tuerkheimer, deborah, yuracko. The variety of feminisms and their contribution to gender equality introduction my focus is the continuities and discontinuities in recent feminist ideas and perspectives. A wildly philosophical exploration of the impact of feminism on the structures and principles that support the legal system. Cases and materials american casebook series 9781683283058. Please write a five page paper 12point font, doublespaced analyzing commonwealth v. Professor ann scales, then a harvard student, moderated a. The gender question 14 woman as other 15 feminist legal methods 19 consciousness raising 19 asking the woman question 21 feminist practical reasoning 23 2 gender inequalities. Introduction to feminist jurisprudence find, read and cite all the research you. Contents preface vii parti the foundations of feminist jurisprudence 1 introduction 3 the e volution and scope of feminist jurisprudence and. Methodologically, feminist philosophy of law draws a great deal from feminist work in other areas of philosophy and has broken new ground as well.
Feminist legal thought may be thought of as a selective field of inquiry, but it is important for legal jurisprudence that all aspects of the law are examined from a variety of theoretical standpoints. So long as law is a form social power takes, an avenue for relief of injury, a right of citizenship, a lever for social legitimacy, and a force in womens lives, feminist jurisprudence. Feminist engagement with law has taken a variety of forms over the years. Hilaire barnett, introduction to feminist jurisprudence. It was not so long ago that feminist, legal, and theory simply did not. By patriarchy feminists mean the ordering of society under which standardspolitical, economic, legal, social are set by, and fixed in the interests of men, men are more valued than women. Feminist jurisprudence, 1993 online research library. However, it does not do so by conducting a historical inquiry designed to restore forgotten female jurists or reveal womens. Feminist jurisprudence argues that we must look at the norms embedded in our legal system and rethink the law. This paper seeks to revive feminist interest in jurisprudence. Examining the concept of feminist jurisprudence sociology. Flt workshops became a part of the very first feminist legal theory. Hilaire barnett ba, llm queen mary and westfield college university of london.
The diversity of feminist philosophy and theory is represented in feminist jurisprudence, but two models of feminist jurisprudence predominate. Feminist jurisprudence is the analysis of law from the perspective of all women. The first three chapters develop the historical range of feminist theories. The variety of feminisms and their contribution to gender. This is the postprint version of the chapter published as feminist legal theory in. The readings in this collection are organized according to the traditional topics in a typical this anthology is designed for. This enables academics to discover and discuss the nature of law as an evolving social institution in a comprehensive manner. Feminists were also involved in efforts to overturn legal restrictions on contraception and abortion. Maria drakopoulou abstract this paper seeks to revive feminist interest in jurisprudence. Feminist jurisprudence 7 irrationality, feeling, emotion, passivity, nature, subjectivity, sensitivity and contextualised and personalised behaviour. There is no original or primary gender a drag imitates, but gender is a kind of. Contents preface vii parti the foundations of feminist jurisprudence 1 introduction 3 the e volution and scope of feminist jurisprudence and feminist legal methods 3 the feminist. This coursebook introduces students to feminist jurisprudence.
As a field of legal scholarship, feminist jurisprudence began in 1960s. Hence, towards a feminist jurisprudence was born, the original description of which read. Continuation the feminist jurisprudence wanted to bring an end to patriarch way of thinking. Feminist jurisprudence thus pioneers a relation between life and law through which womens unequal social reality will be legally confronted and transformed. Feminist jurisprudence is a philosophy of law based on the political, economic, and social equality of sexes. The contemplation of a feminist jurisprudence takes place along these critical lines. A critical appraisal emily jackson law, it could be argued, is peculiarly resistant to novel critical perspectives. Dec 03, 20 a brief powerpoint on the diverse schools of feminist thought and what they entail slideshare uses cookies to improve functionality and performance, and to provide you with relevant advertising. This barcode number lets you verify that youre getting exactly the. The third part of the article discusses the possibility for, the promise of, the obstacles to, and the present status of a truly feminist jurisprudence, which i define as a jurisprudence built upon.
It seems to have taken the form, in its earlier years, of a considered theoretical response by women jurists and lawyers to a widely held perception of american jurisprudence as the product of an exclusively male ideology. However, there are huge ranges of assertions and theories within feminist jurisprudence. Overview feminist jurisprudence is a burgeoning school of legal thought that encompasses many theories and approaches to law and legal issues. Scholarship in this area began in the 1960s, although pioneers agitating for the womens right to vote and other important steps for equality began working much earlier. Victoria davion 1996 journal of social philosophy 27 3. A brief powerpoint on the diverse schools of feminist thought and what they entail slideshare uses cookies to improve functionality and performance, and to provide you with relevant advertising. In other words, maleness is treated as the starting point. See martha chamallas, introduction to feminist legal theory 10 1999. More on challenging essentialism and privileged baselines. Feminism as a theory of law as a concept, feminism is very much a modern notion within legal circles, which aims to eradicate any prejudice against womens rights. Until that philosophical fact changes, the phrase feminist jurisprudence is a conceptual anomaly. Feminist legal philosophy has generated a great deal of interest in recent years, and this is the first collection of readings to cover feminist legal philosophy in a comprehensive way. This anthology is designed for use in courses in feminist jurisprudence, jurisprudence and the philosophy of law.
Feminist jurisprudence, like most feminist theory, rejects the claim of law that it is a neutral practice, and instead points to the ways in which law is clearly not neutral. Interestingly, as recently as two or three years ago, some denied that a feminist jurisprudence had yet developed, preferring to refer to it as feminist. Sociological jurisprudence meaning and introduction to jurisprudence the word jurisprudence derives from the latin term jurisprudentia, which means the study, knowledge, or science of law. Each strain of feminist jurisprudence evaluates and critiques the law by examining the. Feminist philosophy of law stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Introduction to feminist jurisprudence sage journals. In the introduction, smith defines feminist jurisprudence as the. Feminist epistemological accounts of epistemic injustice and the social nature of knowledge are especially salient to many questions about and within law mckinnon 2016. Scales although the conjunction of the terms feminist and jurisprudence might be said to indicate the dogma resulting from the common orientation of a political interest group, the purpose of this article is not to postulate a theory of law which is inherently selfinterested.
Thus, feminist legal theorists have maintained their quest for a specifically feminist jurisprudence, aiming to make moral and legal philosophy more receptive to. Feminist legal theory, also known as feminist jurisprudence, is based on the belief that the law has been fundamental in womens historical subordination. Reasonable women will differ on whether there is or should be such a thing. An analysis of oklahomas sed published by tu law digital commons, 1989. Feminist jurisprudence feminist jurisprudence is a philosophy of law based on the political, economic, and social equality of sexes.
Feminist jurisprudence 1 introduction 3 the e volution and scope of feminist jurisprudence and feminist legal methods 3 the feminist gender debate 14 what is a woman. London sydney first published in great britain 1998 by cavendish publishing limited, the glass house, wharton street, london wc1x 9px, united kingdom. Key concepts queer theory heterosexual matrix performativity. Feminist jurisprudence is an approach to legal scholarship and practice that views the law through a feminist lens to examine the impact of current and past legal trends on the lives of women. Introducing feminist jurisprudence tu law digital commons. Thereafter it discusses the distinctive strands of what i deem to be feminist jurisprudence, before concluding with a call for a feminist reimagining of jurisprudence as an activity both theoretical and pragmatic, and also as one which might hold hitherto unthought possibilities for a feminist analysis and critique of law. Feminist jurisprudence, a term coined as recently as 1978, 2 has completely disrupted the conventional model of jurisprudence. The feminist jurisprudencei, more appropriately the feminist legal theory, focuses basically on genderiiconceptually and women in practice, while the ecofeminist jurisprudence uses the gender just as a base to focus on all other forms of biasness and domination in existence. Feminism in legal jurisprudence and social analysis. Key concepts hegemonic masculinity patriarchal dividend. Liberal legal theory dominates, and one of its fundamental tenets, the doctrine of precedent, inculcates respect for past principles as an article of faith. Informed by the reformist and experiential grounding of feminism, feminist jurisprudence has eschewed the rarefied abstractions of analytical jurisprudence.
305 469 1369 988 985 544 790 292 1285 795 1187 1164 1436 1310 302 1395 1082 1173 551 1264 658 1365 1141 456 1108 1346 100 781 1192 839 633 1257 93 1228 33 1487 54 588 40 622 685 1128 958 722 8 80 1289 155 674 53